What Super Bowl ads do you…
Recall? That’s Ad Effectiveness Hurdle #1.
Ad Effectiveness Hurdle #2 – was the ad likeable? Many ads are recalled and talked about in a negative way. Those advertisers then paid $3.5 million dollars to irritate customers and prospects. (They should have pre-tested their ad.)
Ad Effectiveness Hurdle #3 – can you remember the brand name of the company or product/service that sponsored (paid for) the ad? Or was the ad funny but not well linked to help you recall the ad and the brand who paid for it?
Ad Effectiveness Hurdle #4 – of the ads that you can recall with the proper brand sponsor, what message did you take away after seeing the ad? Was that message persuasive enough to get you to change your mind about something? Reinforce or remind you about something positive about a brand? Was there a “why buy” message that stuck with you?
Ad Effectiveness Hurdle #5 – Did the ad get you to do something (like visit a website, click on a QR code or seek out the opinion of someone you respect to ask about the product/service/company)?
The toughest test:
What ads that ran on the Super Bowl can you say you’d check “all of the above”?
- Recall
- Recall in a positive way
- Properly link the ad to the name of the company paying for the ad
- Remember the message or key point of the ad
- Changed or reinforced (positively) your perception(s) about the brand being advertised
- Influenced you to do something to learn more
- Influenced you to buy
That would be a totally effective ad!
Unfortunately most ads, even ads on the Super Bowl, don’t accomplish all that. Many ads are funny or memorable but they’re not persuasive. You might remember the celebrity in the ad or the joke and maybe you remember what product/service/company was being advertised. David Ogilvy’s belief, “It’s not creative unless it sells” is still totally relevant. The very best advertising drives brand awareness and preference and purchase. That’s a very, very hard job to do in a 30-second spot.
EXTRA CREDIT: Ads that “go viral” and create buzz where millions of people seek out the ad on YouTube and/or share a link to the ad. Ads that David Letterman talks about in a positive way. Those ads should get “extra credit.” They get free air time and more exposure than just 30 seconds on the Super Bowl.
So, with all that as your criteria for a “great ad” on the Super Bowl, what ads met the highest standards from the advertiser’s point of view who shelled out $3.5 million dollars for media placement for one 30-second spot?
The cost to pay the celebrity and produce the ad is then an additional cost so the real cost to the advertiser may be closer to $3.8 or $4.0 million dollars. Yikes. You have to sell a lot of soda, insurance, cars or hamburgers to make up the cost of paying for that advertising.
What ads do you think were the best ROI for the advertisers?
Learn more about Effective Advertising